Which do you prefer, the old car or the new version?
Old Scirocco Vs New Scirocco
Old Golf GTI Vs New Golf GTI
Old Escort RS Cosworth Vs New Focus RS
Old Astra GTE Vs New Astra VXR (You may choose the mk1 Astra if you want, I couldn't find a pic with both cars in the frame).
Personally, I'd choose the new version of each. Nostalgia doesn't play much of a part in selecting cars for me.